The first book in another planned YA trilogy (second book out already, final in 2013). Interesting premise about choosing your family group based on your dominant traits. Throw in some creepy mind reading/control, and you’ve got something pretty fun – even if it does get kinda campy towards the end.
Mystical, bloodthirsty horses rising from the sea? Poor orphan girl struggling to help her remaining family survive? Harsh, windswept setting? Yes, please!
This was a fun, quick read. Yes, there were parts that made me roll my eyes pretty hard. There’s no excuse to forget the characters’ names, as they are mentioned on nearly every frickin’ page. The ending was a bit…conventional? Pat? Whatever. All the horses means overall I was happy. (I like horses.)
Another YA trilogy, centered around a love triangle. Why is it that teenage girls can only see a problem with society when it’s through the lens of a romantic dilemma? Oh, wait – that’s just how it is in some books. Sorry, I’m having trouble containing the snarkiness about this book. I just wonder if the author recognizes the irony in writing about matches and planning and the pitfalls involved when her professed religion… ok, I’ll stop before I get into trouble.
But seriously, I do wonder how LGBT teens and people of color would relate to this book. Heterosexual seems to be the only recognized sexuality. Condie describes her characters pretty well, and they seemed to all be white – or at least, arguabley white. I can’t think of a single one that was definitely a person of color. (Of course, I could be mistaken. I know white readers often read characters as white even when they are intended to be otherwise.) Maybe these are more diverse characters in the second and third books. Maybe Condie puposedly left them out so we can see their exclusion is a problem that needs to be addressed. Maybe. Hopefully.
Have you read any of these? Share your thoughts!